Simprago Logo
Simple & Pragmatic Problem Solving
#92Chapter 6: Group Creative Option Generation• Group Creative OptionsComposite, evolutionary and convergent (Successive Integration) Thinkinggroup Mode60-120 Minutes(time-consuming)

SIL Method

From the book "Advanced Problem-Solving Toolbox: 115 Creative Plays" | Compiled & Edited by: Mojtaba Goudarzi, Open translation: Mehrshid Goudarzi
Executive Synopsis & Core Logic:

German technique of successive integration of solution components; Generating ideas in silence, reading two ideas simultaneously and combining them into a single whole by the group, and then step-by-step integrating other ideas into the evolving solution.

Operational Parameters & Specifications

Category
Group Creative Options
Dominant Thinking
Composite, evolutionary and convergent (Successive Integration)
Participation
group
Estimated Timetime-consuming
60-120 Minutes
Workshop
Input Format
problem statement, individual raw ideas written in initial silence
Output Format
idea generation and creation of an evolved integrated solution
Key Application
designing comprehensive customer loyalty programs, developing integrated organizational processes, integrating multiple product concepts and designing service packages.
Core Differentiator:

evolutionary movement like a snowball; Ideas are pinned and integrated into the body of a central solution rather than a long list of individual ideas on the board.

Quick Field Example:

To build the retail customer club, the team first combines the idea of ​​the points system and the idea of ​​silver/gold levels; Then he links the third idea (exclusive business partner discounts) to the same plan.

Operational Benefits & Implementation Risks

Advantages & Value Creation:

Building extremely rich, mature and seamless solutions, tremendously fostering the spirit of cooperation, making the most of individual members' ingenuity.

Risks & Potential Trade-offs:

Meetings are time-consuming due to in-depth discussion around each integration cycle, requiring flexibility for members to change their personal ideas.

Real-World Organizational & Industry Scenarios

Customer Club Service Design: Building an Online Retail Loyalty Platform with Stepwise Integration of Reward and Gamification Ideas.
Hybrid product engineering: development of a home robot by step-by-step integration of navigation, cleaning and security monitoring ideas.
Redesigning the organizational structure: developing a performance evaluation process by successively integrating the suggestions of line employees and staff managers.

Strategic Rationale & Why to Apply

1Big solutions are built from small parts: No single idea is enough for today's complex problems.
2Eliminating envy of ideas: because the second idea is combined with the first and the third with the result of the two, all members are parents of this solution.
3Continuous sifting: Weak ideas are automatically refined in the merging process and their best core is merged into the main body.
4Continuity and Continuity of Thought: The team's focus throughout the session is on completing a single project, not jumping from branch to branch.

Conceptual Framework & Book Method Description

The SIL method, which stands for the German term 'Sukzessive Integrationsmethode von Lösungselementen' (method of successive integration of solution elements), was developed at the Battle Institute in Frankfurt. The process begins with individual ideation in silence. Two members then read their ideas out loud, and the team is tasked with integrating the two ideas into a coherent composite concept. A third person reads his idea and the group fuses it with the previous mixed concept. This cycle continues until an evolved and robust solution is formed.

Step-by-Step Real-World Implementation Scenario

to design a comprehensive loyalty program and customer club for an online store
1
Step 1: Individual BrainstormingTeam members (UX designer, financial expert, marketing and support manager) wrote down their ideas independently.
2
Step 2: Reading the first two ideas and initial integrationExpert A read the idea of ​​'earning points per purchase' and Expert B read the idea of ​​'Bronze, Silver and Gold membership levels'; The team combined the two into a 'stepped scoring system with an exponential rate at higher levels'.
3
Step 3: Integrating the third idea (gamification)Expert C read the idea of ​​'round of luck and weekly missions'; Added to previous plan: 'Silver level users get double points for completing weekly missions'.
4
Step 4: Integration of the fourth idea (ecosystem of partners)Expert D read the idea of ​​'cinema and cafe discount'; Combined with the previous plan: 'The points earned at different levels can be converted into business partners' entertainment vouchers'.
5
Step 5: Final Polishing and Unveiling of the PlatformThe integrated solution was implemented under the name 'Galaxy Rewards Club' and the return rate of buyers grew by 42% in the first month.

Is this play relevant to your team or organization?

Share this structured playbook guide directly with colleagues or across your network.

Previous Play (#91)
Scenario Writing
Next Play (#93)
Storyboarding
Analytical Q&A & Field Discussions

Share your reflections or inquiries regarding this play or chapter with the author.

Comments are published after review
No operational dilemmas posted yet. Be the first to initiate an empirical discussion.

Submit Operational Challenge

Your inquiry is routed directly to the Simprago moderation panel for review and official response.

Submissions include anti-spam checks